Subject: Re: C458: PFPC: An Infrastructure for Research on Parallelizing Compilers Resent-Date: Fri, 03 Nov 2000 12:20:10 -0500 Resent-From: Geoffrey Fox Resent-To: Geoffrey Fox Date: Fri, 3 Nov 2000 16:06:05 +0800 From: "CT Yang" To: "Geoffrey Fox" Dear Prof Fox: I am very sorry for my delay in revised and resubmitted our paper to you. We have read the referees' comments very carefully, and modified the paper according to the comments. We prepared a revision and a brief summary of revisions (From for Response to Review) in the attached document. We have worked hard in revising the paper, and now are sure that the paper has been improved. We have re-organized the paper to strengthen our contribution. Please contact me for further correspondence. We greatly appreciate your help and attention. We look forward to hearing from you soon. Thanking you. I remain, Sincerely yours, Chao-Tung Yang, Ph.D. Associate Researcher, Mission Center Group Leader Ground System Section, National Space Program Office ctyang@nspo.gov.tw http://aho.cis.nctu.edu.tw/~ctyang tel: +886-3-5784208 ext. 1563 fax: +886-3-5779058 ----- Original Message ----- From: Geoffrey Fox To: Chao-Tung Yang Sent: Monday, October 02, 2000 6:15 AM Subject: C458: PFPC: An Infrastructure for Research on Parallelizing Compilers > I regret that I did not get back to you about this paper which should > have been reviewed much earlier. I enclose a single short referee report > -- we have waited too long for the others and will go with this. > > I would be happy to publish your paper if you addressed the changes > suggested by the referee. This looks non-trivial but doable quite quickly to me. > Please include a discussion of your changes and their answer to the > referee in your resubmittal. If this is persuasive, we can publish your paper > without further refereeing. > > I thank you for your interest in Concurrency:Practice and Experience. > Please send all communication -- including the resubmission -- electronically > if possible using the address > fox@csit.fsu.edu > > > If you should need a "real address", please use: > Geoffrey Fox > Computational Science and Information Technology > Florida State University > 400 Dirac Science Library > Tallahassee Florida 32306-4130 > 850-644-4587 but easiest is cell phone 3152546387 > > Referee Report > ----------- > This is an interesting paper suitable for the Concurrency:Practice and Experience > journal. I recommend that the authors > 1) Improve the english. It is quite good but still a bit quaint at places > 2) Focus the paper on the essential contribution "Knowledge-based Sysatem" and > change title/organization/abstract etc. accordingly. The other material can > be kept as it has pedagogical value but viewed as "context" > 3) Have a crisp section really evaluating value and potential of their appreoach > as compared to other efforts in academia/commercial world --------------------------------------------------------------------- Name: T0016.ps T0016.ps Type: Postscript Document (application/postscript) Encoding: quoted-printable Name: T0016RE.ps T0016RE.ps Type: Postscript Document (application/postscript) Encoding: quoted-printable