Comments on Letter Basically excellent I think some of the terminology is confusing -- in particular the word "integration" which can be understood in many ways. For instance is integration with a small i on page 3 under software or page 2 when discussing physics modules same as integration with capital I on page 5? They are related but different I think I believe Integration refers to macroscopic integration of program components. "integration" to software and algorithms needed to link multidisciplinary codes or just modules within a code I would spell out "Views" as Visualization and Data Management so all topics have English not Acronym Titles Under "spectacular computational science" I would say that ASCI is the world leader in developing and linking large applications and has demonstrated both in the core program and the Alliances remarkable simulation on large scale parallel computers of complex multidisciplinary science. This computational science tour de force is critical for Stockpile Stewardship but also is a beacon for simulation-based science in industry and academia. The software (problem solving) environments developed in ASCI are the most sophisticated in the world. Under software, I could say Although ASCI's current problem solving environments activities are excellent, there is remarkable progress in industry and academia in core software technologies driven by the Internet. These emerging ideas need to be evaluated and inserted as appropriate into the ASCI environment. State of the art software is no less important to ASCI than having the best available hardware and we suggest a strategy of "software technology insertions" roughly every 3 years as is done with the hardware. ASCI can expect industry to supply base software technologies but currently it does not seem likely that commercial organizations will supply the needed high performance computing environments. ASCI needs an overall software plan addressing life cycle costs and technology enhancements within the context of an architecture that addresses the needs of ASCI and the lewverage of commercial developments.