N body problems (e.g. Newton's laws for one million stars in a globular cluster) can have succesful special purpose devices
|
See GRAPE (GRAvity PipE) machine (Sugimoto et al. Nature 345 page 90,1990)
-
Essential reason is that such problems need much less memory per floating point unit than most problems
-
Globular Cluster: 10^6 computations per datum stored
-
Finite Element Iteration: A few computations per datum stored
-
Rule of thumb is that one needs one gigabyte of memory per gigaflop of computation in general problems and this general design puts most cost into memory not into CPU.
|
Note GRAPE uses EXACTLY same parallel algorithm that one finds in the books (e.g. Solving Problems on Concurrent Processors) for N-body problems on classic distributed memory MIMD machines
|